The clock was making me faster at the wrong thing. What happened when I put it away.
For about two months I timed every ladder. I kept a spreadsheet of seconds, and I noticed something odd: my times improved while my routes got sloppier. I was getting faster at moving the cursor and slower at planning, and the spreadsheet could not tell the difference.
The problem is that a timer rewards whatever ends the puzzle soonest. That is not the same as the cheapest route. Under a clock, a legal two-step gambit looks better than a careful backward pass, because the gamble takes two seconds to try. Do that enough times and you learn to gamble, which is exactly the habit that fails on long routes.
I put the clock away and replaced it with a single question after each solve: did I walk the route I planned, or did I improvise? That question is slower to answer than a stopwatch but it points at the thing that actually improves with practice.
There is nothing wrong with speed. A player who can see a route quickly is a good player. The issue is training speed before route quality, because the two habits fight each other in the first year. Timing rewards the wrong one. If you have never played this daily word ladder, the contrast is easy to feel: play one puzzle carefully and one against a stopwatch and notice which one you want to do again.
The experiment I would suggest is two weeks without a clock, with one note per day about whether you followed your plan. That is the only metric I have found that rewards the thing I want to be good at. If you want to see the difference for yourself, visit the site and play a round with the clock deliberately ignored; most people find the second half of the route gets calmer immediately.